Lovecraftian Commander Decks?

Kracken, Merfolk maybe - Eldrazi perhaps. I suspect you could get something in Blue / Blue-Black maybe? Between the Eldrazi and the Phyrexian sets you might find some appropriate creatures.

It sounds interesting.

Perhaps yes - there are cards like Whispering Madness, Descent into Madness etc that could get interesting.

Mill is always a possibility

I think he was one of the pre-release foils. If he wasn't then I appear to have 2 plus a foil one somehow.

I like him as a commander but I'd also kind of like Thassa - more from a gameplay point of view than a flavor one.

Oh yeah - this is something you'd have to actually allocate time to doing as it would mean going through a LOT of cards before you even nail down the colors you wanted to run - Lovecraft did do fish men but also did a lot of stuff based around pure psychological horror which may not need blue. You'd have to chose the aspect you were going for.

Probably the only thing you could say is that you wouldn't be all that likely to play Red.... even white though - Elish Norn, Suture Priest...

Lol

Will review it fully tomorrow. Will also try to dig out my anthology (brought in Waterstones Picadilly no less) and have a read